Syndicate
|
Stay up to date with the Cosmic Fantasia RSS feed
|
|
|
Support Builds for Labour, Environment Standards |
|
|
|
|
Written by Jim Lobe
|
|
Thursday, 22 March 2007 |
(IPS) - Strong majorities in both developing and
developed countries believe that international trade agreements should
require governments to abide by minimum labour and environmental
standards, according to a new survey of public opinion in 10 countries.
Of the 10 countries covered by the survey released Thursday by the Chicago
Council on Global Affairs (CCGA) and WorldPublicOpinion.org (WPO), support
for such provisions was highest in the United States, Israel, Argentina
and Poland. In those countries, nine or more of every 10 respondents said
they favoured such provisions.
But more than eight of every 10 respondents in China, Ukraine, and Armenia
also said they supported the inclusion of minimum standards in trade
accords, according to the survey, which was carried out during the second
half of last year.
Of the remaining three countries covered by the survey, support was
strongest in Mexico and weakest in India and the Philippines.
"It has often been assumed that when leaders of developing countries argue
against including labour or environmental standards in trade agreements,
they represent the wishes of their people," said Steven Kull, WPO's editor
and director of its parent organisation, the University of Maryland's
Programme of International Policy Attitudes (PIPA) "It has often been assumed that when leaders of developing countries argue
against including labour or environmental standards in trade agreements,
they represent the wishes of their people," said Steven Kull, WPO's editor
and director of its parent organisation, the University of Maryland's
Programme of International Policy Attitudes (PIPA).
"However, it appears that these publics would like to see the
international community put pressure on their governments to raise their
standards," he added.
The survey was part of a 17-nation study to assess attitudes on specific
global issues. CCGA and WPO said the survey results will be released issue
by issue over the coming weeks and months. In addition to the 10 countries
covered in the survey results released Thursday, the larger project
included Russia, Thailand, Iran, South Korea, Australia, Peru, and the
Palestinian territories.
Many developing country governments have opposed the incorporation of
labour and environmental standards in bilateral and multilateral trade
agreements because of fears that they would reduce the attractiveness of
their economies to foreign investment. They have also charged that such
measures have been used to protect domestic industries in the rich
countries.
The administration of U.S. President George W. Bush has also opposed such
standards -- particularly those that require the imposition of severe
penalties against offending countries for violations -- on the grounds
that they interfere with the "free market" and could force the U.S. itself
to adopt stricter labour and environmental laws.
But last November's landslide election victory by Democrats, who now enjoy
majorities in both houses of Congress, has forced the administration to
alter its position, particularly with respect to labour standards.
Earlier this month, the administration proposed that, in exchange for
Congress extending its so-called "fast-track", also known as
"trade-promotion" authority to negotiate new trade agreements with other
countries that cannot later be amended by Congress, it would require those
countries to pass laws that were either "equivalent" to U.S. federal
labour law or that comply with the conventions of the International Labour
Organisation (ILO) in Geneva. Its current "fast-track" authority will
expire in June.
The new survey found near-unanimous support in the U.S. for imposing both
labour (93 percent) and environmental (91 percent) standards in trade
agreements.
"The American public is clearly concerned that trade agreements fail to
protect either workers or the environment," according to CCGA's
Christopher Whitney. "This strengthens the hand of those in Congress who
share this apprehension, particularly as the White House increases its
willingness to negotiate these issues with Congress in advance of the June
expiration of the president's trade promotion authority."
In the new survey, some 13,000 randomly selected individuals were
interviewed by local polling firms in the 10 countries. Each was asked
whether countries "that are part of international trade agreements should
or should not be required to maintain minimum standards" for working
conditions and for the environment In the new survey, some 13,000 randomly selected individuals were
interviewed by local polling firms in the 10 countries. Each was asked
whether countries "that are part of international trade agreements should
or should not be required to maintain minimum standards" for working
conditions and for the environment.
On the labour question, the U.S. topped the list with the greatest
percentage of support, followed immediately by Israel, while, on the
environmental question, Israel was the most supportive, with the U.S.
claiming the second position. The rankings, in descending order, of the
remaining eight countries -- Argentina, Poland, Ukraine, China, Armenia,
Mexico, India and the Philippines -- were the same with respect to both
questions.
One of the most interesting findings was the marked contrast between
Chinese respondents, 84 and 85 percent of whom favoured labour and
environmental standards, respectively, and their Indian counterparts, of
whom only 56 percent and 60 percent, respectively, supported the two sets
of standards.
Representing nearly 30 percent of the world's population, the two Asian
giants are widely seen as the emerging powerhouses of the global economy
that also face serious challenges both in narrowing the gap between their
rich and poor populations, containing greenhouse gas emissions, and
reducing pollution caused by rapid industrialisation.
Also significant was the gap between the two Latin American countries
covered by the survey. While nine in 10 Argentines voiced near-unanimous
support for labour and environmental standards, respondents in Mexico, a
founding member of the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA), which
included largely toothless labour and environmental standards, were
notably less supportive.
Two-thirds (67 percent) and three-quarters (76 percent) of Mexicans
supported labour and environmental standards, respectively.
By far the least supportive of both kinds of standards were Filipino
respondents. Despite a long history of exporting workers, many of whom
have suffered abuse abroad, only 55 percent of Filipinos said they
supported labour standards. They were even more divided with respect to
environmental standards. Forty-eight percent said they favoured their
inclusion in trade pacts, while 49 percent said they were opposed.
By contrast, 69 percent of respondents in nearby Thailand said they
supported environmental standards. Thai respondents, however, were not
asked their views about labour standards.
Source: IPS - Inter Press Service News Agency
|
|
Featured Screensaver Our Leonardo da Vinci screensaver celebrates the genius of the man and displays 54 of his greatest artworks (some with different versions), drawing scientific studies and drawings. Download Screensaver
More Screensavers
|