Syndicate
|
Stay up to date with the Cosmic Fantasia RSS feed
|
|
|
Clash of Civilisations Not Inevitable, Poll Finds |
|
|
|
|
Written by Jim Lobe
|
|
Tuesday, 20 February 2007 |
(IPS) - A violent clash between Islam and the West is
not inevitable, according to a majority of respondents in a survey of more
than 28,000 respondents in 27 countries released Monday.
An average of 56 percent of respondents agreed with the proposition that
"it is possible to find common ground" between members of the two
faiths -- twice the percentage who agreed that "violent conflict is
inevitable" between Muslim and Western cultures, according to the survey
by BBC, the University of Maryland's Programme of International Policy
Attitudes (PIPA), and Globescan.
"Most people around the world clearly reject the idea that Islam and the
West are caught in an inevitable clash of civilisations," said PIPA
director Steven Kull.
The survey, which was carried out by locally contracted polling firms
between November and January, covered five predominantly Muslim
countries -- Lebanon, Egypt, Turkey, United Arab Emirates, and
Indonesia -- as well as several others, including Kenya, Nigeria and
India, with significant Muslim populations The survey, which was carried out by locally contracted polling firms
between November and January, covered five predominantly Muslim
countries -- Lebanon, Egypt, Turkey, United Arab Emirates, and
Indonesia -- as well as several others, including Kenya, Nigeria and
India, with significant Muslim populations.
It also included overwhelmingly Christian nations, including the three
countries of North America -- the U.S., Canada, and Mexico; three South
American countries -- Argentina, Chile, and Brazil; and nine European
nations, the Philippines, and Australia.
China and South Korea were also included.
On the question of whether Muslim and Western cultures could find common
ground or whether violent conflict between them was inevitable, Muslim
respondents tended to be somewhat more pessimistic.
Thirty-five percent of Muslim respondents overall -- boosted by a 51
percent majority in Indonesia -- said they believed conflict was
inevitable, compared to 27 percent of Christians and other non-Muslim
respondents who took that position.
But the answer often depended on how well-educated respondents were,
according to the survey. Among those who told interviewers they had no
formal education, only 46 percent said they thought common ground between
the two cultures was possible. By contrast, almost two out of every three
respondents with post-secondary educations gave that answer.
The survey also asked respondents whether they thought tensions between
Islam and the West arose more from differences of religion and culture or
from conflicts over political power and interests. Overall, 52 percent
chose the latter option, while only 29 percent chose the former.
Remarkably, a 56-percent majority in Nigeria, half of whose population is
Muslim and concentrated in the North, and 40 percent is Christian and
concentrated in the southeast, said they thought tensions were due mainly
to differences in religion and culture. In Kenya and Poland, respondents
were roughly split on the question.
At the opposite end of the scale, the view that political power and
interests were the main cause of tensions between the Islamic and Western
worlds was most widely held in Lebanon (78 percent), Mexico (72 percent),
China, (62 percent), and South Korea (61 percent).
Asked whether tensions arose from fundamental differences between the
cultures as a whole or from intolerant minorities within them, 58 percent
chose the latter option, and 26 percent agreed with the former.
Of the 58 percent majority, moreover, 39 percent said that the intolerant
minorities existed on both sides of the religious divide, while 12 percent
placed the main blame on the Muslim side, and seven percent on the Western
side.
The belief that fundamental differences, as opposed to intolerant
minorities, were most responsible for tensions between the two cultures
was also strongest in Nigeria, where 50 percent of respondents took that
position, Egypt and Portugal (39 percent), the UAE (37 percent), Brazil
and the Philippines (36 percent), and Lebanon and Indonesia (35 percent).
The belief that intolerant minorities on both sides were mainly
responsible was most widely held in France and Australia (68 percent), and
Mexico (67 percent), while 28 percent of respondents in Indonesia and one
in five respondents in Italy, Egypt, Kenya, and India put most of the
blame on intolerant minorities in the Islamic world.
Besides Indonesia, the view that violent conflict between the Islamic and
Western worlds was inevitable was most widely held in Egypt (43 percent);
the Philippines and Germany (39 percent); Nigeria (37 percent); and Kenya
(35 percent). In each of those countries, however, pluralities or
majorities still agreed that it was finding common ground was more likely
than conflict.
Countries where the largest majorities believe that Islam and the West can
find common ground included Italy (78 percent), Britain (77 percent),
Canada (73 percent), Mexico and France (69 percent).
The countries where respondents were least likely to say they thought
common ground was possible included India (35 percent); Indonesia (40
percent); the Philippines and Hungary (42 percent); Chile (45 percent);
Argentina, Poland, and Kenya (46 percent); the UAE (47 percent); and
Turkey, Russia, and Germany (49 percent).
German respondents were also significantly more likely to believe that
violent conflict was inevitable (39 percent) than any other European
country.
As to the U.S., 64 percent said they believe it is possible to find common
ground, compared to 31 percent who agreed that violent conflict was
inevitable.
Source: IPS - Inter Press Service News Agency
|
|
Featured Screensaver Our Leonardo da Vinci screensaver celebrates the genius of the man and displays 54 of his greatest artworks (some with different versions), drawing scientific studies and drawings. Download Screensaver
More Screensavers
|